Posted: April 2nd, 2017

Read the arguments presented by your classmates and analyze the reasoning that they have presented. Comment on the strength of their reasoning.

‘Responding to peers .Discussion 1
Read the arguments presented by your classmates and analyze the reasoning that they have presented. Comment on the strength of their reasoning. Help them out by pointing out any respect in which a reasonable person might disagree with the truth of their premises or with the strength of their reasoning.Give suggestions for how the argument might be improved.
PEER 1
Argument: Is torture ever permissible?
Premise One: Torture will not institutionalize the interrogator.
Premise Two: The interrogator is doing a job to extract information when there is a substantial threat to the community.
Premise Three: Any normal person would torture if…’ REVIEW: ‘Hand shake went great. Kept their side of the agreement and asked question about the homework before accepting.’